Recent controversies surrounding Kamal Haasan's movie Vishwaroopam or
Ashish Nandy's alleged anti-Dalit comment were reflection of a society which
seems to be increasingly becoming a culture of "competitive intolerance", Union
Minister Shashi Tharoor has said.
The events over the last week which also saw writer Salman Rushdie being denied
entry into Kolkata "do not speak well of us", he regretted.
Emphasising on striking a careful balance in one's expression so as not to hurt
any sentiment and incite violence, Tharoor said the country has not yet reached
to a position where freedom of speech should include the right to offend.
"It should in my view include the right to say things that might offend some and
therefore invite a counter argument and discussion and debate, but not to the
point where a government or a judge determine that it is poses a danger to
public order," he told Karan Thapar on CNN-IBN's the Devil's Advocate
programme.
"The challenge for us as a society is got to be to find the right balance that
leans more towards freedom and not towards repression."
Asked about Nandy's alleged anti-Dalit remarks, Tharoor, who is the Minister of
State of HRD, replied there were "legitimate grounds of disagreeing" with what
the sociologist had said but calling for arrest as demanded by some political
class was totally "unnecessary".
He, however, felt Nandy could have phrased his remarks in a better way to avoid
offending anyone.
The Minister maintained that a ban on Haasan's movie Vishwaroopam should not
have been imposed, especially when it was certified by the Censor Board.
"...Once the film has been certified by the Censor Board it ought to be screened
and if you don't know what the film says, then engage with the film makers,
argue if necessary, protest if you must but do not prevent screening...," he
said.
Giving an overview of all these issues, Tharoor said the disturbances witnessed
during the past week were because "we seem to be increasingly becoming a culture
of competitive intolerance".
Emerging story. Watch this space for updates as more details come in
© Copyright PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of any PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.