Feb 09, 2010
 
PTI / Courtesy TV 9
MNS MLAs Assault Abu Azmi for Oath in Hindi
Click to Share
In an unprecedented incident,  Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) MLAs today attacked Samajwadi Party legislator Abu Azmi inside the state assembly for taking oath in Hindi and not in Marathi marking a violent debut for Raj Thackeray's party in the House.

Stung by what Chief Minister Ashok Chavan called as "goondagardi" (hooliganism) by MNS never witnessed in the House, the Assembly acted tough and passed a resolution suspending four MNS members from the House for four years within hours after the chaos. The MLAs were also accused of misbehaving with a woman MLA.

The resolution moved by parliamentary affairs minister Harshvardhan Patil to suspend Shishir Shinde, Ramesh Vanjale, Ram Kadam and Vasant Geete was approved by voice vote.

Stating that hooliganism will not be tolerated, Chavan also did not rule out action against MNS chief Raj Thackeray saying this will be taken if the video footage of his reported comments outside the Assembly showed he had instigated his party MLAs.

The three-year-old MNS, which returned 13 members to the House, all first timers, unleashed chaos during the oath taking by the new MLAs in a turbulent start to the maiden session of the 12th state Assembly.

The proceedings in the backdrop of the so-called diktat by Raj Thackeray that all members must take oath in Marathi or face the consequences went on smoothly until Azmi's turn came when he was manhandled by MNS members who pushed and punched him for insisting that he would take oath only in Hindi.

Ram Kadam allegedly slapped and hit Azmi on the chest and shoulders while Ramesh Vanjale snatched the microphone and uprooted the podium as a result of which the paper from which he was reading out his oath fell.

As Azmi began reading out the oath in Hindi, the MNS members tried to shout him down and asked him to switch over to Marathi. When Azmi remained defiant, they menacingly advanced towards him.

The SP leader, who picked the paper up and continued reading out the oath, was seen engaged in a heated argument with the MNS legislators as the House was drowned in din leading to a 30-minute adjournment.

As Azmi was being roughed up, some MNS members were seen carrying banners and shouting pro-Marathi slogans. MNS MLAs surrounded Azmi from all sides when the House had hardly been adjourned.

Ashok Chavan and energy minister Ajit Pawar rushed to calm the frayed tempers.

Speaking to reporters outside the House, an unfazed Azmi defended his decision of taking oath in Hindi and said he had done nothing to warrant such action by the MNS MLAs.

But an unrepentant Ram Kadam justified his action saying Azmi's insistence on taking oath in Hindi betrayed his lack of respect for Marathi language and people.

The incident evoked widespread condemnation across the political spectrum with demands being made for stern action against the erring MNS MLAs.

Ashok Chavan said Constitution of India allowed members to take oath in any language. The four suspended members will not be allowed to enter the premises of the Assembly in Mumbai and Nagpur, he said.

Buoyed by the impressive Assembly debut of his party, Raj had recently announced his legislators would ensure that all MLAs took oath in Marathi taking the politics of regional chauvnism straight to the Assembly.

"If any MLA does not take oath in Marathi, the House will see what happens," Raj had threatened. Raj issued a reminder today, asking all 287 MLAs in the House to take oath in Marathi.

"This is a blot on democracy in the state. I condemn the incident. The government will deal with those who take law into their hands," Chavan said.

MNS leader Bala Nandgaonkar took objection to the resolution and said it was Azmi who had provoked his colleagues and demanded action against the SP leader.

Shiv Sena-BJP alliance members abstained when the resolution suspending the four MLAs was approved.

Parliamentary Affairs Minister Harshvardhan Patil said the conduct of the four suspended MLAs was "most condemnable" and against the highest tradition of the House.

"This act had tarnished the image of the august House and hence amounts to breach of privilege," Patil said.

MNS members also tried to brush past PWP member Meenakshi Patil who tried to intervene as they were assaulting Azmi. BJP group leader Eknath Khadse said the way MNS members had behaved with the woman member had maligned the image of the House.

The MNS members’ fury, which was in full flow as Azmi took oath, was, however, missing, as some members, including former minister Baba Siddiqui, took oath in languages other than Marathi.

Siddiqui, Congress MLA from Bandra, took oath in English. Girish Mahajan, BJP member from Jalgaon, took oath in Sanskrit.

Azmi later told reporters that he had full respect for Marathi language. He demanded suspension of MNS members for the entire five-year term and arrest of Raj Thackeray.

"I had given notice to Legislature officials 10 days ago that I would be taking oath in Hindi," he said.
Filed At: Nov 09, 2009 15:09 IST ,  Edited At: Nov 09, 2009 18:02 IST
© Copyright PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of any PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.
Comments:

Nov 15, 2009 06:51 PM
15
Hridayanandji...This is not a war between Hindi and Marathi... Its just that Abu Azmi is equally responsible. And this is my personal opinion so no question of drawing inference over Marathi people from my comments.
Pushkar, Pune
Nov 15, 2009 11:26 AM
14
pushkar must be nuts, as is raj thakra and his supporters, or is it the true face what a idiotic people marathis are
hridyanand pandey, new york
Nov 10, 2009 12:54 AM
13
Abu Azmi is a gangster who is in cohorts with Dawood .. we all knwo that very fact that he is chummy with Amar Singh gives away all his crednetials.. that;s not the point.. Point is open goondagardi UP assembly style in Maharahstra assembly
Anil Kumar, Toronto
Nov 10, 2009 12:53 AM
12
Reminds me of Bhindrawale episode where to check Akali dal congress raised a frankstein called bhindrawale.. They never learn from history anything is game in name of grabbign power.. i only hope this Raj Thackreye doesn;t becomea Bhindatrawale.. Indifference towards langauge hatred is being tolerated by congress/NCp other wise within minutes MCOCA could be invoked and Raj thackrey put behind bars for inciting hatred towards lingusitic minority in maharahstra but no such thins is being done..
Anil Kumar, Toronto
Nov 10, 2009 12:51 AM
11
Congress can;t keep getting benfit of doubt always.. They knew what MNS does and what ti stands for.. Their open demand was for all of us to see. Either congress/ncp should have reasoned with Abu Azmi the gangster to just memorize four sentences in marathi if not they should have made arrangment of marshals to check the goondaism of MNS..

They did neither fully knowing MNS gaining currency bodes weel for NCP/COngress combine as was shown in last assembly elections if not for MNS BJP Shiv sena
Anil Kumar, Toronto
Nov 10, 2009 12:29 AM
10
Why is it not being brought to notice that it was Abu Azmi who showed his footwear first.Then was he assaulted by MNS.All news show violence of MNS only, however Abu Azmi started it off.
Pushkar, Pune
Nov 09, 2009 10:57 PM
9
Bastards.
Samirajan, Portland
Nov 09, 2009 09:26 PM
8
Hubris have struck Marathis. Just as they struck Punjabis some time back when they began claiming that Punjab contributes much more to India than what India contributed to Punjab.
Bhindrawale rose in that environment.

Look where is Punjab today-it has still not really reovered from the loss of respect, love and affection that Indians earlier gave Punjabis. Punjab has lost its position on other parameters too. Bhindrawale died in 1984-and this is 2009.
Maharashtra, Marathis and Raj-deja vu
Atul Chandra, mUMBAI
Nov 09, 2009 08:48 PM
7
va raj saheb va,
etaka hindicha pulka aala asel tar ja mhana u.p. la aani kar tuzi kashi.
Abhijeet Kumbhar, Mumbai
Nov 09, 2009 08:46 PM
6
Derocognize MSN party. Put Raj Thakrey in Jail.
andy, Mobile
Nov 09, 2009 08:16 PM
5
A member of the house is attacked by some goons because he spoke in Hindi not in Marathi as ordered by the goons. What a joke on Democracy. Does raj Thackeray knows there's something called "freedom of expression" in constitution? So shall rest of the Indians start beating/hitting marathis outside Maharashtra? Is this he wants to teach us? We are very proud to claim ourselves as "biggest democracy" in the world, is this what democracy means?
S Singh, Hyd
Nov 09, 2009 07:56 PM
4
Raj Thackeray moving on the path of bhidrenwale...Toughest action should be taken against such people who demonstrated unconstitutional behaviour in the assembly. MNS should be banned in the assembly because they are taking such things on surface from last 2-3 years... Its pathetic....where is home minister of state....why people from MNS had not been arrested and put behind the bars. I mean how they could do such act in assembly..as if they are doing things in their home..this is not acceptable
Pradeep Sharma, Mumbai
Nov 09, 2009 06:24 PM
3
It is unbecoming of Members of Legislative Assembly to use force for airing their grievances. While, the MNS have every right to uphold and honour their mother tongue, they must not violate the FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION guaranteed to every citizen, under the Constitution of India. If the MNS desire to fulfill their demand, they must strive to ensure relevant Constitutional Amendment and make it a LAW.
ANOOPAM MODAK, DELHI
Nov 09, 2009 04:39 PM
2
well said anuja
hridyanand pandey, new york
Nov 09, 2009 03:23 PM
1
What rubbish is this?
"If any MLA does not take oath in Marathi, the House will see what happens," Raj had threatened.
And the House, the new CM, the Speaker, other MLAs - absolutely no-one is going to open their mouth??? Why do we need a House in that case... Raj thackeray can hold the durbar in his own aangan
Anuja, Delhi

Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY